Help Me Pick

Hey y'all! I've been working on lengthening a short-story (originally called "Let's Make a Deal"). The rights revert back to me on May 1st. I'm hoping to get it up to novella length by adding back in deleted scenes and so on. This story kind of kicked off the whole Marriage & Mayhem series. It's about Joe Matthews and Sarah Asher. Here's what Publisher's Weekly said about it...

“‘Let’s Make a Deal’ is a diverting story by newcomer Crystal Barnes that conjures a headstrong young woman of the Old West. She agrees to an arranged marriage but stands her ground when it comes to consummating the union—until she actually falls in love.”

—Publisher’s Weekly, for “Let’s Make a Deal” from A Kiss is Still a Kiss: A Short Story Collection

I'll be re-releasing it under a new title -- Signed, Sealed, & Delighted. But first I have to settle on a good cover. I could really use y'all's opinions.

Which cover do you like best?
Which catches your eye first?